Resolute Square

Double Bind: Why Republicans Could Face A Historic Defeat in 2024

Published:February 29, 2024

By Brian Daitzman

As the United States approaches the 2024 presidential elections, the Republican Party is facing a complex dilemma that could presage a historic defeat.

On one side, nominating former President Donald Trump, who has been found liable for fraud and sexual abuse and is subject to multiple criminal indictments, could result in significant defections within the party. This scenario would likely impede its ability to appeal to a broader electorate beyond Trump’s core supporters. If Trump were to secure the nomination, there’s a tangible risk that moderate Republicans and Republican-leaning independents may either leave the party or opt to support President Biden.

Conversely, choosing not to nominate Trump—particularly if a criminal conviction further undermines his electability—risks alienating his steadfast base. This could provoke Trump to retaliate against the GOP, potentially jeopardizing its prospects. Should the GOP seek to replace Trump due to a criminal conviction, it would then face the daunting task of unifying a deeply fragmented base, torn between pro-Trump loyalists and a substantial anti-Trump contingent. Trump’s capacity to disrupt party unity, whether by urging his supporters to abstain from voting or by initiating an independent write-in campaign, could spell a catastrophic loss for the Republicans.

Both scenarios present severe implications for down-ballot Republican candidates, potentially compromising the party’s performance broadly and situating the party in a predicament with no apparent victory.

Early primary exit polls from states such as Iowa, New Hampshire, and South Carolina reveal significant internal discord within the GOP, challenging Trump’s claims of unwavering party support. Approximately 30% of GOP primary voters staunchly oppose his nomination, and a notable portion of Nikki Haley’s supporters, about 25%, refuse to back Trump, with some even contemplating support for President Biden or abandoning the party altogether. The internal division is further accentuated by the contrasting support bases of Trump and Haley: Trump attracts predominantly white, evangelical, and less-educated voters, while Haley appeals to a younger, potentially more moderate, and college-educated demographic. This fragmentation underscores the difficulties in unifying the GOP base and highlights the party's internal schisms.

Trump’s legal entanglements, including four criminal indictments encompassing 91 felony charges, loom large over his political future and the Republican Party’s prospects in 2024. These issues not only threaten to further mar his candidacy but also risk alienating moderate and independent voters, potentially disassembling the GOP’s electoral coalition. The shadow of legal troubles, especially if they lead to a conviction before the November vote, poses a significant threat to the party’s cohesion and electoral chances. The potential effect of a criminal conviction on Trump’s candidacy is significant, with a notable portion of voters, including those in pivotal swing states, indicating an unwillingness to support him if convicted.

The widening gender gap, with a significant preference for Biden over Trump among female voters, further complicates the GOP’s path to victory in 2024. This trend is amplified by issues such as reproductive rights following the Dobbs decision, presenting a substantial electoral challenge for Trump, who has historically struggled to connect with female voters. The backlash from women voters, particularly concerning the implications for IVF treatments and pregnancy loss, underscores the potential of this issue to decisively influence the 2024 elections.

As 2024 looms, the Republican Party faces the potential for a strategic defeat, compounded by internal divisions, legal challenges confronting its potential nominee, and misalignment with crucial voter concerns. The state of the national and state parties, weakened by years of Trump’s dominance, adds to these challenges, marking the forthcoming election as a critical juncture for the GOP’s future.


  • A Conservative Environmentalist?
    The Enemies List

    Rick Wilson's The Enemies List

    Conservatives in America are not typically known as lovers of environmental advocacy. Well, our guest bucks that trend. Benji Backer, an environmental advocate and author of "The Conservative Environmentalist" joins Rick to discuss the urgent need for practical and innovative solutions to environmental challenges, critiquing both extreme denial and radical approaches currently dividing the political landscape. Backer emphasizes a historical bipartisan approach to environmental issues and proposes a balanced pathway that leverages American ingenuity and respects local knowledge.
    April 15, 2024
  • Trump's "Sledgehammer" Problem
    That Trippi Show

    That Trippi Show

    One spoiler down, another to go. No Labels is out of the Presidential fight - but Joe gets into why Trumpland is feeling good about RFK Jr. - including funneling $20m from a top donor his way. How is the media still missing the point about all these spoilers? Plus - can Trump actually talk his way out of his big abortion problem? Joe explains why the problem runs much, much deeper than most realize. And why the GOP is all in, sledgehammer or not.
    April 12, 2024
  • AI Apocalypse
    The Enemies List

    Rick Wilson's The Enemies List

    It feels like all anyone wants to talk about these days is how AI is taking over. Well, we thought it time to have an expert on to break it all down. In this episode Rick speaks with AI expert Daniel Faggella in a comprehensive discussion on the evolving landscape of artificial intelligence. They speak to the implications of AI on the workforce, economy, and society, examining both the current state and future possibilities. Faggella brings insights from his experience in market research, discussing how AI is reshaping industries from legal to entertainment. They explore the concept of artificial general intelligence (AGI), its accelerated timeline, and potential societal impacts. The conversation also touches on the role of AI in politics, the concept of a political singularity, and the ethical considerations of AI development.
    April 10, 2024
  • Fox News: Celebrities Who Love MAGA and the Damn Dirty Democrat Earthquake!

    Decoding Fox News

    Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson said he wouldn't endorse Biden in 2024. He also didn't endorse or praise Trump. Fox News tried to make a lot out of random celebrities complaining about things. Kid Rock praised Trump while failing to disclose that Budweiser is sponsoring his latest music tour. The Five blamed an earthquake on Democrats. There was a lot of bigotry against transgender people. Matt Whitaker misrepresented Bill Clinton's sock drawer scandal along with the Presidential Records Act.
    April 10, 2024
  • The (Very Good) Politics Related To Student Debt Relief
    A deep-dive into John Della Volpe's recent polling on an issue that could go a long way in deciding the outcome of the election.
    April 9, 2024