Resolute Square

Contingent Election – A Return To Smoke Filled Rooms

Fmr. Congressman Martin Frost writes, "No Labels has lost the argument that its candidate could win the election. Their fallback argument is a return to smoke-filled back rooms where party bosses decide who becomes president. How can the No Labels crowd say they stand for Reform with a straight face?"
Published:March 25, 2024
Share

By Martin Frost

One of the crazier ideas being pushed by No Labels is that they could play a key role in a contingent election of a new president by the House of Representatives if neither the Democratic nominee (Biden) nor the Republican nominee (Trump) receives a majority (270) of the Electoral Votes in 2024. The No Labels candidate couldn’t actually be elected but could make “deals” to throw the election to one of the two major party candidates. How do you think the public would like that?

In order for this to happen, one of two things would need to occur: (1) the Electoral Vote would need to be tied at 270 for Biden and 270 for Trump, or (2) A third-party candidate would need to carry several states so that neither Biden nor Trump won at least 270 Electoral Votes.

A third party candidate carrying several states is a high hill to climb since Electoral Votes are determined winner-take-all according to the popular vote state by state in 48 states. The most recent third-party candidate to win a substantial popular vote was Ross Perot, who won 19 percent of the total popular vote in 1992 but did not win a single Electoral Vote since he did not win ANY states.

The other scenario (a 270-270 tie) would not trigger a three-way contingent election since the Constitution provides that any contingent election in the House would be between the top three finishers of the Electoral Vote. A third-party candidate would not make the runoff since the No Labels candidate would not receive any Electoral votes. That is exactly what happened in the 1800 election when Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr tied in the Electoral Vote.

If a contingent election were to occur for the 2024 election, each state would get one vote. Thus California and Wyoming would get a single vote for president despite their great difference in population. Sound fair?

Each state’s single vote would be determined by a caucus of its House members. A collection of small states, each with only one or two House Members, could tip the election to the candidate who lost the national popular vote.

No Labels has lost the argument that its candidate could win the election. Their fallback argument is a return to smoke-filled back rooms where party bosses decide who becomes president. How can the No Labels crowd say they stand for Reform with a straight face?

NOTE: Former Congressman Martin Frost (D-Texas, 1979-2005) was Chairman of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee in 1996 and 1998 and Chairman of the House Democratic Caucus from 1999 to 2002.

Related

  • Autocracy Looms, Democracy at Stake
    The Enemies List

    Rick Wilson's The Enemies List

    In these final days before the election, Trump has doubled down on his authoritarian, fascist rhetoric. To help us make sense of the chaos leading up to the big day, Rick welcomes historian and political analyst Heather Cox Richardson for a thought-provoking discussion on the future of American democracy. Together, they delve into the stark contrasts between democracy and authoritarianism, the Republican Party’s transformation under Trump, and the growing influence of tech billionaires pushing anti-democratic agendas. With the 2024 election upon us, they examine the stakes, the shifts in voter sentiment, and the potential for new political coalitions to reshape our reality.
    November 4, 2024
  • Good news for Kamala, Trump's turnout problem & Bold Predictions? With Tom Bonier
    That Trippi Show

    That Trippi Show

    Our friend and data guru Tom Bonier joins the show to figure out what's real and what isn't with just days to go. Is early voting good for Democrats? Or just different? And what is going on with all these yo-yoing polls? Where are Tom and Joe most confident headed into the final weekend before Election Day - and what's everyone's bold prediction for the election? This is it, everybody. Go vote! Check vote.org to confirm your registration and make a plan to vote. You can see more of Tom's work at https://targetearly.targetsmart.com/.
    November 1, 2024
  • The Free World vs. Him: Alexander Vindman on Trump's Foreign Policy
    The Lincoln Project Podcast

    The Lincoln Project Podcast

    Alexander Vindman offers his foreign policy take on what a second Trump presidency would mean for the United States and the good of the civilized world. Follow Alexander Vindman on X at @AVindman and read and subscribe to his Substack at alexandervindman.substack.com. Follow Rick Wilson at @TheRickWilson on X and subscribe to his Substack at therickwilson.substack.com. Join the fight with Lincoln Project at www.lincolnproject.us and follow us on X at @ProjectLincoln.
    October 31, 2024
  • A McDonald's Nothingburger With A Side of Fascism

    Decoding Fox News

    Donald J. Trump was lauded as a political genius for cosplaying as a minimum wage worker at a McDonald’s franchise while The New York Times published an audio interview of Gen. John F. Kelly describing Trump as a fascist and admirer of Hitler. Fox decided to bury the story in a heap of French fries prepared by the same wannabe dictator Kelly was trying to warn the American public about. Everyone clutched their pearls to dust after Kamala Harris called Trump a fascist. Stephen A. Smith verbally mopped the floor with Sean Hannity in an amusing and delightful extended rant.
    October 30, 2024
  • THE Frank Rich joined Rick, Stuart, and Joe!
    Strategy Session

    Strategy Session

    Well now, that was fun! Frank Rich, award-winning journalist, and Emmy and Golden Globe winning Executive Producer for shows including VEEP and Succession, joined Rick, Joe, and Stuart last night for a super-smart, riveting, and fun conversation. Catch up now!
    October 29, 2024