Resolute Square

What Journalism Isn’t

Mark Jacob writes: "Journalism isn’t easy, but it’s damn important, and more people in the news industry need to start doing it before they wake up one day and realize that journalism has become illegal."
Published:September 16, 2024
Share

*Read more of Mark's outstanding work in his Stop The Presses newsletter.

By Mark Jacob

Journalism isn’t the mere act of turning on the microphones and letting politicians talk.

Journalism isn’t inviting proven liars to come on your TV show and lie to your audience, and then thanking them for it. 

Journalism isn’t a process for normalizing a madman.

Journalism isn’t blaming “politics” or “division” instead of blaming the people who play politics and divide us.

Journalism isn’t entertainment.

Journalism isn’t done for the benefit of journalists. 

Journalism isn’t listening to a lie by a lifelong liar and pretending to your audience that he might be telling the truth this one time. 

Journalism isn’t a game of access that’s won when you avoid asking hard questions and doing follow-ups.

Journalism isn’t thinking the purpose of politics is to create a dramatic competition you can cover, rather than a way to choose leaders who will make people’s lives better.

Journalism isn’t describing plain old racism as something that’s “racially charged” or “racially tinged.”

Journalism isn’t presenting poll numbers as if they’re vote totals.

Journalism isn’t easily distracted.

Journalism isn’t reflexively finding fault with “both sides” as a posture of objectivity.

Journalism isn’t writing passive headlines that suggest a bad thing happened for some mysterious reason, even though the story itself tells you who was responsible. 

Journalism isn’t throwing shade on positive news by using lame phrases like “doubts remain” or “the future is uncertain.”

Journalism isn’t helping unnamed sources take anonymous potshots at their enemies.

Journalism isn’t treating crime statistics as less important than the vibes of people in diners.

Journalism isn’t thinking one side’s lies and the other side’s truths constitute a “debate.” 

Journalism isn’t self-promotion. 

Journalism isn’t pretending dangerous people are not dangerous people because you don’t want those dangerous people coming after you.

Journalism isn’t using a campaign’s talking points as your list of questions when you interview their opponent.

Journalism isn’t ignoring important news because your competitor broke the story. 

Journalism isn’t trivial.

Journalism isn’t presenting political criminals as amusing characters.

Journalism isn’t nodding your head during an interview as if you think the newsmaker is saying something reasonable, even though you know it’s batshit crazy. 

Journalism isn’t the process of inventing clever euphemisms, such as praising a flip-flopping politician’s “ability to massage her message to the moment.”

Journalism isn’t interested in minimizing fascism.

Journalism isn’t assuming the best from the people who always give us their worst.

Journalism isn’t measured by clicks.

Journalism isn’t measured by ratings.

Journalism isn’t measured by salaries.

Journalism isn’t a task that’s possible if you tolerate lies.

Journalism isn’t easy, but it’s damn important, and more people in the news industry need to start doing it before they wake up one day and realize that journalism has become illegal.

Related

  • "The biggest BS line ever devised by anyone ever"
    That Trippi Show

    That Trippi Show

    Trump's going off the rails. And there's nobody left to stop him. Why his lawsuits against ABC and Ann Selzer aren't only ridiculous - they're really dangerous. And those tax cuts? Why Joe and Alex aren't holding their breaths. And how about all those tariffs bringing down inflation and gas prices? Joe thinks this might be Trump's biggest lie of all time - and that's saying something. Finally - handing Elon the keys to the government - what could go wrong? Read Dan Gilmor's newsletter, Cornerstone of Democracy, here: https://cornerstone.ghost.io/essentials-december-17-2024/
    December 20, 2024
  • ABC's Dangerous Capitulation
    The Enemies List

    Rick Wilson's The Enemies List

    Today Rick details the chilling effect of ABC's capitulation in a lawsuit brought by Trump, examining its dangerous implications for press freedom and journalism in America. He warns that this decision sets a precedent, emboldening Trump and others to intimidate media outlets into silence through lawsuits, threats, and governmental pressure. He explores how corporate interests, fear of retaliation, and the erosion of trust in the media are undermining the free press—a cornerstone of democracy.
    December 18, 2024
  • Frame Warfare: The Right's Battle For Your Brain
    One of the first pieces Resolute Square published was this by Dr. Jen Mercieca in Dec. 2022. It's essential reading today with Trump poised to return to the White House because right-wing framing is dangerous to democracy - and it's becoming more intense.
    November 27, 2024
  • Treason To The Democratic Way Of Life
    With little more than a week until election day, fascists and authoritarians are working feverishly to end American democracy. If we don’t “do democracy,” Dr. Jennifer Mercieca warns, they might succeed.
    October 25, 2024
  • Lies, Lies, and More Lies
    The Enemies List

    Rick Wilson's The Enemies List

    How do we fact check in an ocean of lies? In this episode Rick is joined by Bill Adair, the founder of PolitiFact and a professor at Duke University, to discuss the growing epidemic of political lying, especially within the Republican Party. They explore the history of political dishonesty, the role of conservative media in amplifying misinformation, and the challenges of fact-checking in an era dominated by figures like Donald Trump. The conversation highlights the danger that widespread deception poses to democracy and addresses the role of new technologies, like deepfakes, in further distorting truth in political discourse. Bill's book, Beyond the Big Lie: The Epidemic of Political Lying, Why Republicans Do It More, and How It Could Burn Down Our Democracy, available now.
    October 21, 2024