Resolute Square

What Happens If There Is A Presidential Election And No One Wins?

Martin Frost writes, "What happens if a candidate with a famous name like Kennedy actually carries a few small states with a total of 18 electoral votes? Bingo – no one wins." That's when things really go off the rails.
Published:April 23, 2024
Share

By Martin Frost

What happens if we have a presidential election and no one wins?

Now that Robert Kennedy Jr. is in the race running as an independent, it is possible that you could have a result on election day that no one gets the 270 electoral votes to win. Let’s say that Biden and Trump each get 260 electoral votes, and Kennedy wins several states with 18 electoral votes. The total number of electoral votes is 538, and Kennedy’s 18 electoral votes hold both Biden and Trump under the magic number of 270.

How is this possible? It’s because of a fatal flaw in the electoral college system – electoral votes in all but two states are determined winner-take-all. Whoever receives the most votes in each of 48 of our states wins 100 percent of the electoral votes in each of these states. There is no proportional representation. If you lose any of these states with 47 percent of the popular vote and your major opponent gets 49 percent of the popular vote, he gets all of the electoral votes in each such state. Only Maine and Nebraska have different systems.

A third-party candidate like Kennedy could tip the electoral vote in a number of states by receiving as little as four percent of the popular vote. Independent candidate Ross Perot got 19 percent of the popular vote in 1992 but won zero electoral votes because he didn’t carry a single state.

But what happens if a candidate with a famous name like Kennedy actually carries a few small states with a total of 18 electoral votes? Bingo – no one wins.
Under our constitution, the election is then decided by the House of Representatives, with each state having only one vote. Our most populous state, California, gets one vote, and a small state like Wyoming gets only one vote. The election would be decided by the new House, which takes office on January 3rd.

Republicans currently control a majority of state delegations in the House of Representatives Trump could be elected by the House even if the Democrats take back the House if the Republicans still control a majority of the state delegations. This could be possible because many of the small state delegations are likely to remain Republican.

Enter Bobby Kennedy Jr. Because he has a famous name and the general population knows very little about some of his bizarre positions on issues, he could throw the election to Trump either by tipping the popular vote to Trump in some states or by actually carrying some small states. That’s why a large number of Kennedy family members recently held a press conference disavowing their famous relative and endorsing President Biden.

Their message was simple – a vote for Bobby Kennedy Jr. is a vote for Trump.

Former Congressman Martin Frost (D-Texas, 1979-2005) was Chairman of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee in 1996 and 1998 and Chairman of the House Democratic Caucus from 1999 to 2002.

Related

  • The GOP’s Trap...Will Democrats Fight Back?
    The Enemies List

    Rick Wilson's The Enemies List

    Politics is a battlefield, and right now, Democrats are struggling to break free from the traps set by Republicans. In this episode Rick Wilson sits with Democratic strategist Joel Payne to discuss the current political landscape and the challenges facing the Democratic Party. They break down the Republican Party’s attempts to box Democrats in on spending bills, the broader cultural and messaging battles, and how Democrats can better connect with voters by focusing on real-world concerns rather than policy jargon. Payne offers insight on the evolving political spectrum, the need for Democrats to fight smarter, and how Trump’s chaos-driven approach presents both challenges and opportunities
    March 17, 2025
  • It's Not Play Dead Time!
    That Trippi Show

    That Trippi Show

    Are we buying Putin's latest con job? Why Joe and Alex think the proposed "ceasefire" in Ukraine might be broken before it's even agreed to. And returning home, Joe and Alex finish their look at the state of our union. What's going on with the economy - and why has Trump seemingly already broken one of his signature promises? How much pain are Trump supporters willing to take? And Joe lays out what Democrats can fight for - rather than just rolling over.
    March 14, 2025
  • As Trump Implodes Fox Disses Democrats

    Decoding Fox News

    As the stock market tumbled and Trump’s approval ratings continued to drop the folks on Fox cherry-picked biased polls, mislead their viewers about tariffs, repeated the president’s lies about immigration and demonized Democrats.
    March 13, 2025
  • You Did Not Vote For THIS!

    Punching Up with Maya May

    The Oligarchs are in the White House with their Teslas parked out on the front lawn. But this didn’t just happen. What seems like sheer chaos is the result of a four-decades-long systematic plan to dismantle our democracy. It is the greatest transfer of wealth and power in world history, and the billionaires convinced half of us that it was done on our behalf. Anne Nelson, author of “Shadow Network: Media, Money, and the Secret Hub of the Radical Right,” joined Maya to break down how it all happened - and what the hell we can do about it because you didn't vote for this!
    March 13, 2025
  • Trump’s Revenge Tour and Other Nightmares with Alex Isenstadt
    The Enemies List

    Rick Wilson's The Enemies List

    What really fueled Donald Trump’s 2024 comeback? In this episode Rick sits with journalist and author Alex Isenstadt to discuss his new book, Revenge: The Inside Story of Trump's Return to Power. They dive into Trump's campaign strategy, his ability to harness cultural resentment, and the political maneuvers that secured his victory. From his outreach to young male voters through podcasts to the decisive role of figures like JD Vance and Elon Musk, Isenstadt provides an insider's perspective on how Trump reshaped his movement. They also explore the psychological impact of the assassination attempt in Pennsylvania and how it further galvanized his supporters.
    March 12, 2025