Resolute Square

Comparison Is The Thief Of Joy

Andra Watkins writes, "Such Christian Nationalist women vote against their own interests because they envy other women’s lives and regret their own choices."
Published:December 3, 2024
Share

*Andra Watkins is an award winning author, survivor of Christian Nationalism and an expert on Project 2025. Read and support her important work here: For Such A Time As This


By Andra Watkins

As a survivor of Christian Nationalism, I’m calling bullshit on this explanation. My experiences indicate Christian Nationalist women vote for 45 and Republicans because of two profound emotions: ENVY and REGRET.

Many Christian Nationalist women ENVY women who had choices they believe they lacked, either because of the misogynist CN interpretation of the Bible or their own fear of what might happen if they made a contrary choice. Compounded by the Social Media Envy Factory, they watch other women get advanced degrees, pursue careers, get abortions, delay motherhood, date around, and be child-free. These women had the power to set boundaries, travel the world, make their own decisions without a man’s permission, and choose themselves first.

Envy is a potent emotion. Often, it is fueled by REGRET.

The regrets of Christian Nationalist women can flow along these lines: I should have gone to college. I wish I had finished college instead of dropping out and getting married. I should have waited until I was older to get married. I wish I’d married a different man. What would my life be like if I didn’t have children? I’d love to travel instead of being in church every time the doors are open. Where would I be now if I had divorced my husband instead of staying because the Bible condemns divorce? I wish I had a career instead of depending on my husband for everything. I’m so tired of submitting to my husband.

red Wrong Way signage on road
Photo by Kenny Eliason on Unsplash
Such Christian Nationalist women vote against their own interests because they envy other women’s lives and regret their own choices.

They may lack introspective tools to identify and cope with these emotions. Bible reading, prayer, and church attendance don’t make these feelings vanish; over time, they fester into a more toxic stew. Consequently, they vote to force all women to be as unhappy as they are. If I can’t make this choice, by God, neither will you.

Here’s how that plays out in real life:

  • Why should you get an abortion when I had babies I didn’t want? If you don’t want to be pregnant, keep your legs closed.
  • And don’t cry to me about rape or assault, because I give it to my husband all the time when I don’t want to.
  • You shouldn’t be able to get an easy divorce when the Bible says I can’t leave my husband, no matter how much he abuses me.
  • I’ve had to live with the constant dread of another pregnancy because my pastor says contraception causes abortions. You shouldn’t get to swallow a pill and escape that burden.
  • When I say I don’t think women can lead, I really mean I envy women with ambition. It gives me joy to knock them down a few pegs.
  • My only job as a Christian Nationalist mother is to groom my children to play their godly life roles. I’m livid that any of my children bucked their role, and I want to punish them for making me look like a failed mother.
  • Especially when that child announces they are LGBTQ or transgender. Those things reflect badly on me and my mothering, and since that’s the only way the church assigns me any value, I won’t stand for it.
  • Why should you get to travel the world when I sit in church week after week after week? I can’t wait until my vote makes your life as small as mine.
  • My husband won’t let me work outside the home. Why should you get to have a fulfilling career and your own money when I can’t?
  • I can’t use my voice, and I can’t wait until my vote forces you to shut up.


Most Christian Nationalist women would deny such thoughts or feelings, but they are indoctrinated to distrust self-analysis and reflection. If a CN woman admits a sliver of such emotion, she is immediately lectured to stay in her place. A Bible is shoved in her face, where someone (usually a man) shows her why she is wrong. She may be humiliated via anonymous prayer requests that turn into public shaming in the form of prayer. Or she might be shunned until she gets her heart right with God and falls in line. Her children could either be punished along with her or recruited to force her surrender.

The emotional, mental, and psychological abuse is relentless. Instead of fighting, many CN women resign themselves to their indoctrination. ENVY and REGRET morph into a malignancy that rots them from within, leading to another powerful emotion: DENIAL. Since they feel powerless to change their own situations, they do the next-best thing: They punish other women who have what they can’t or won’t allow themselves to have.

Related